“Monumental and stunning in every sense of those words, GBSR Duo and Taylor MacLennan’s approach to these seminal three Morton Feldman works offers both insight and immersion into the composer’s incredible sound world.”
Launching into the new year with a remarkable sense of ambition and energy, Another Timbre returns to their longstanding dedication to work and legacy of Morton Feldman with Trios, one of their most ambitious releases to date. An astounding X6CD box set, comprising new recordings by three of the UK's most exciting emerging instrumentalists - the GBSR Duo (pianist Siwan Rhys and percussionist George Barton) and the flautist Taylor MacLennan - of three of Feldman's most important and celebrated late period works - ‘Why Patterns?’ (1978), ‘Crippled Symmetry’ (1983) and ‘For Philip Guston’ (1984) - across its incredible six and a half hours of music, we are immersed in the composer's incredible sound world and suspension of time, infused with rich and emotive dimensions rarely previously heard.
Few labels have left such an indelible impact on the current landscape of avant-garde and experimental chamber music as the English imprint Another Timbre. Working at remarkably prolific pace, for more than a decade and a half they have delivered a startling array of releases, bridging the fields of modern classical composition, free improvisation, electroacoustic composition, and well beyond, that have been remarkable in their collective efforts to build context, not only commissioning new renderings of historically significant works by contemporary players, but releasing important new works by many of the most vibrant artists working in the field today, including Maria Ahti, Jürg Frey, Magnus Granberg, Julia Eckhardt, Catherine Lamb, Marco Baldini, Biliana Voutchkova, Sarah Davachi, Jim O'Rourke, Judith Hamann, Cassandra Miller, and a near countless number of others. Running like a spine through Another Timbre’s catalog is a deep commitment to the work of Morton Feldman (1926-1987), with more than half a dozen releases having been so far dedicated to the composer. Their latest, ‘Trios’, is quite possibly the most ambitious and striking of these to date.
Born in New York City in 1926 to Jewish, Russian immigrants, of all the avant-garde composers to emerge during the post-war period, Morton Feldman’s career and legacy are among the most fascinating to engage with and track. One of the key members of the New York School - the emergence of which signaled a new place for American artists within the international music scene - Feldman began studying piano at a young age and became an early devotee to the avant-garde, thanks to encounters with the work of Arnold Schoenberg and Anton Webern at a young age. Following studies with Wallingford Riegger and Stefan Wolpe, he met John Cage in 1950 and quickly joined the composer’s circle, including artists like Robert Rauschenberg and Philip Guston, and the composers Henry Cowell, Virgil Thomson, and George Antheil. Not long after, Feldman began composing the radical body of work for which he would become famed - characterized by floating rhythms, soft pitch shadings, and slow evolutions and developments centered around recurring asymmetric patterns - placing him at the centre of the emerging avant-garde and experimental music scene, alongside Cage, Christian Wolff, and Earle Brown.
While unquestionably influential during his lifetime, Feldman often fell under the shadow of more famous peers like Cage, a reality not always helped by the distinct qualities of his work that set him outside the dominant trends of a given moment and a commitment to extreme duration that seemed to increase as he progressed. Particularly relevant to the latter, the composer’s work was often incredibly impractical (if not outright impossible) to release on vinyl. It has only been since the emergence of the CD during the 1980s and 1990s that recording his long-form works has begun to be approached, and even then only a small number of times given the huge commitment and cost of doing so. Thus, it has been only in recent decades, following Feldman’s passing in 1987, that a broad range of listeners are able to encounter his work outside of live contexts, illuminating his singular vision that prefigures Minimalism with its profound sense of constraint, control, and spaciousness, leading to his relatively new found celebration as arguably the most important and influential composer of his immediate peers. In this light, Another Timbre and GBSR Duo with Taylor MacLennan’s brand new collection of newly commissioned renderings of ‘Why Patterns?’, ‘Crippled Symmetry’ and ‘For Philip Guston’ - composed between 1978 and 1984 - represents an important contribution to the interpretations of Feldman’s efforts, each piece having been only recorded a handful of times prior.
GBSR Duo is the percussionist, George Barton, and the pianist Siwan Rhys, who both individually and together have been recently carving important pathways within the UK’s contemporary music scene, regarded for their “fearless, intense and boundary-crossing performances” of Twentieth-century modernism as much as current composers with whom they have instigated new commissions and collaborations. ‘Trios’ is their fourth full-length, following releases dedicated to the work of Barbara Monk Feldman, Eva-Maria Houben, and James Opstad, all of which were also issued by Another Timbre. They are joined by the London based, Scottish flutist, Taylor MacLennan, who, with Rhys, is also a member of Explore Ensemble, as well as working with Southbank Sinfonia, BBC Symphony Orchestra, English National Opera, the Oxford Philharmonic, and the Scottish Ballet.
‘Why Patterns?’ (1978), ‘Crippled Symmetry’ (1983) and ‘For Philip Guston’ (1984) - roughly unified by their instrumentation of flute, piano, and percussion - are among Feldman’s most celebrated late period works, encountering the composer delving toward states of suspended time through the use of extended duration and pacing; the introduction of precise notation, in contrast to his early uses of graphic and indeterminate scores; the use of repetitive patterns; and an increased focus on the timbre and decay of specific sounds. Embarking upon this new phase of his work, during this same period the composer founded the ensemble, Morton Feldman and Soloists - including himself, the flautist Eberhard Blum, pianist Nils Vigeland and percussionist Jan Williams - as a vehicle for their realisation and composing specifically for them, offering insight into the specific points of inception for each of the works comprised by this collection. That said, despite belonging to this new phase in his career, the first piece encountered on ‘Trios’, ‘Why Patterns?’, might be regarded as something of a “bridge” work between the concerns exemplified by Feldman’s earliest and later efforts.
Similar to a number of his works from the 1950s, ‘Why Patterns?’ was written as an uncoordinated score - each of its three instrumentalists, playing piano, flute, and glockenspiel, proceeding through assigned material independently - that is heavily focused around repetition and different permutations of pattern (intervallic and durational) and only finds the players falling into alignment toward the end of the work. Despite culminating around a half-hour in duration - thus markedly shorter than the other two pieces comprised by the collection - and distinct in aspects of its composition from the broader concerns that mark Feldman’s latter efforts, ‘Why Patterns?’ is still remarkably coherent with its companions through its presentation of time and rigorous focus on detail.
Like each of the renderings by Siwan Rhys, George Barton, and Taylor MacLennan encountered on this collection, this new recording enters a thin but existing context of previous recordings attending to it, not the least of which are a 1978 recording from State University College, Fredonia, New York, of Feldman playing it himself with Eberhard Blum and Jan Williams and a 1990 recording played by Blum, Williams, and Nils Vigeland (Morton Feldman and Soloists) - thus the performers for whom it was written in mind and arguably knew the piece the best - setting up a weighty circumstance for contrast. Despite this, Rhys, Barton, and MacLennan make a worthy contribution, drawing out the piece’s intrinsic qualities, sculpting an atmospheric sound-world within which sound patterns rise and fall within the most subtle terms and time seems to dissolve.
Similarly, the collection’s second piece, 1983’s ‘Crippled Symmetry’, was written specifically for Eberhard Blum, Nils Vigeland and Jan Williams, and has been treated to two separate recordings / releases by Feldman and Soloists, among a small number by others. Like its predecessor, it is also built around asymmetrical patterns, with its players proceeding in independent unsynchronized movements. That said, there are significant distinctions. ‘Crippled Symmetry’ expands the instrumental palette of piano, flute, and glockenspiel to also include vibraphone, celesta, and bass flute, and embarks upon a far greater sense of scale and scope, clocking in at roughly an hour and a half in duration, recalling Feldman’s own words on the subject: “Form is easy - just the division of things into parts. But scale is another matter. It requires a heightened kind of concentration.” As such, ‘Crippled Symmetry’ is an immersion into a total sound world within which memory is challenged and a relationship to time seems to fade as its shimmering tones and tense conjunctions rock and sway, rendered by Rhys, Barton, and MacLennan with a striking sense of delicacy that, while largely intangible, offers something slightly more inviting than many of the previous recordings attending to the work.
‘Trios’ concludes with its most ambitious and sprawling work, not to mention one of Feldman’s most famous efforts: 1984’s contemplative epic, ‘For Philip Guston’, dedicated to his friend the painter, who had passed away four years prior, while they were estranged. Written for piano, celesta, vibraphone, marimba, glockenspiel, tubular bells / chimes, and flutes, it incorporates the largest palette of sound sources of the three, and extends to more than four and a half hours in duration, just shy of that of his second ‘String quartet’, completed the year prior. Feldman compared the slow unfolding of totality and space within his late music to the interwoven colors of a Persian rug, a sentiment that the trio of Rhys, Barton, and MacLennan gracefully move the work’s hushed tones, clusters, hazy rhythms, and flirtations with the melodic, imbuing its glacial evolutions and suspensions of time with the deep sense of emotiveness from which Feldman wrote, making a striking contribution to the slim body of recordings previously attending to the work.
Monumental and stunning in every sense of those words, GBSR Duo and Taylor MacLennan’s approach to these seminal three Morton Feldman works offers both insight and immersion into the composer’s incredible sound world.
Originally published by Soundohm.